Editor's Choice


To ICASA or not to ICASA wireless modules?

29 May 2019 Editor's Choice Telecoms, Datacoms, Wireless, IoT

Customers frequently ask me whether or not it is necessary for Otto Wireless Solutions, as the distributor of wireless products, to apply for and receive ICASA approval specifically for wireless modules, prior to selling them.

Chris Viveiros.
Chris Viveiros.

There are a lot of common misperceptions in the electronics design industry concerning this subject. Increasingly, I have heard this line from customers: “But I thought you (the supplier, Otto Wireless) don’t need to have ICASA approval on the modules, because I have to get ICASA approval on my finished product anyway.”

So is this true? Does this statement hold water? Could we as Otto Wireless Solutions be wasting time and money by diligently acquiring ICASA approval for every product we sell?

Prior to looking for an official response, let me perhaps make our position clear: as a company, it is not only about ICASA. We strive to provide high-quality products to our customers, who can make use of any product we sell to them with absolute peace of mind, because what we have supplied is not only type approved, but has the local backing and technical expertise of a responsible company, invests in local testing and approval, and employs staff capable of providing technical support. When customers come to Otto Wireless Solutions, they know exactly what they are paying for, and accordingly, over time we earn the trust of our clients.

What does the law say about this? ICASA stands for Independent Communications Authority of South Africa. It is a regulatory body set up to regulate and enforce the Communications Act. Therefore, if one is uncertain, one can consult the Communications Act of 1996, which can be downloaded from various government websites.

The Act itself was set up with a number of specific agendas in mind, one of which was to make provision for the regulation of telecommunication activities other than broadcasting, and for the control of the radio frequency spectrum. Any supplier or customer who finds themselves unsure of whether or not they have an obligation to acquire ICASA approval, can simply download the Act, and review the opening clause of chapter VI, section 56 (1) which states: No person shall supply telecommunication facilities or equipment unless, subject to subsection (2), he or she has been registered by the Authority.

The definition of ‘equipment’ may, at the outset, seem somewhat vague, but if one consults section 54, it explains that the Authority may prescribe what ‘equipment’ entails. In summary, the need to ensure that GSM, LoRA, Wi-Fi and other RF modules which we sell are ICASA approved, is prescribed by law.

Once I explain the above to customers, they then sometimes fall back on argument number two, and this question is: “But if you as Otto Wireless Solutions have ICASA approval on device XYZ, then the product is approved and I can purchase from any supplier.”

This is also a misperception. The Act mentioned above is clear that it is both the certificate holder and the equipment which are ICASA approved. Secondly, the ICASA approval certificate lists the company name on the certificate, ensuring that both the device and the certificate holder are approved.

Lastly, the ICASA type approval certificate itself is doubled sided, and on the back it spells out the standard conditions, which oblige the holder of the type approval to notify ICASA of changes to the product, but also makes it clear that the certification itself is not transferable (see clause 1.5): This type approval certificate is not transferable and the holder shall not transfer it to any other person or entity, nor surrender it in any way in favour of another, except with the written approval of ICASA.

It is very clear that an ICASA type approval is valid only when purchasing from the certificate holder.

Which brings me to the underlying concern which some customers have expressed: does this mean that when we supply our ICASA approved (for example) LoRa module to a customer, and they design it into their application, is our ICASA approval null and void? Of course the device itself remains approved, but this approval does not ‘carry forward’ to include the customer’s final product.

Once the customer has taken a product and used it in their application, it is the customer’s responsibility to have their final product ICASA approved. This is necessary because a client may have, for example, inadvertently amplified the device’s performance, or their product may, in some other ways, be operating outside of safety specifications. This makes it necessary for clients to have their final products approved, regardless of whether or not they have decided to purchase an ICASA approved module.

So there is a benefit in purchasing ICASA approved modules. The benefit is in knowing one has purchased a product which is operating within ICASA’s type approval limitations. When submitting a final product for testing, which integrates the approved module into a design, the ICASA approval of the module can be put on the table, often mitigating the level of testing which needs to be carried out, and subsequently reducing the cost of product approval tests. If the final product is found to be failing EMC emissions, the module itself can be excluded as a potential cause of noise, because it operates within known and acceptable emission parameters.

In conclusion, when selecting a wireless module, purchasing an ICASA approved device or module from the approved supplier is critical. Not only does this start the design off with peace of mind, but in the long run it can very well save you valuable time and money.

For more information contact Otto Wireless Solutions, +27 11 791 1033, [email protected], www.otto.co.za



Credit(s)



Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Potential risks of plasma treatment on PCBs
MyKay Tronics Editor's Choice
Plasma treatment involves exposing PCBs to an ionised gas, known as plasma, but despite many advantages, several risks must be managed to ensure safe and effective plasma application in EMS.

Read more...
X-band radar
RF Design Editor's Choice Telecoms, Datacoms, Wireless, IoT
X-band radar systems, particularly those leveraging beamforming ICs (BFICs), advanced gallium nitride (GaN) and gallium arsenide (GaAs) components, are leading the way in providing the high-performance radar capabilities required for modern defence and surveillance.

Read more...
Remote provisioning firmware added to SIMCom modules
Otto Wireless Solutions Telecoms, Datacoms, Wireless, IoT
SIMCom recently announced that its range of Cat 1 bis IoT modules are now being prepared with the firmware necessary to support SGP.32 functionality.

Read more...
LED driver for industrial power supply indication
Altron Arrow Editor's Choice Circuit & System Protection
A simple and small solution for driving an LED to provide visual feedback in the presence/absence of a system’s power using a chip not originally designed for this purpose.

Read more...
Case Study: Siemens Valor automation solution
ASIC Design Services Editor's Choice Manufacturing / Production Technology, Hardware & Services
Electronics manufacturer BMK used Siemens Valor to enhance accuracy and speed up bill-of-materials quotations.

Read more...
Four ways to enhance IoT battery performance using emulation software
Concilium Technologies Editor's Choice
Battery life affects the cost and reliability of IoT-based infrastructure and is a key purchasing consideration for consumer electronic IoT devices.

Read more...
NuWave Technologies: Excellence in electronic component procurement
NuWave Technologies Editor's Choice
Based in Randburg, Gauteng, NuWave Technologies is built on core values of integrity, honesty, transparency, and service excellence.

Read more...
Arduino platform with Analog Devices technology for flexible industrial control
Altron Arrow Editor's Choice DSP, Micros & Memory
Software-configurable systems enable industrial OEMs to deliver unprecedented flexibility to the factory floor, while simplifying product complexity.

Read more...
Accelerating RF PCB design in a 5G world
ASIC Design Services Editor's Choice Design Automation
Billions of IoT devices coming online in the coming years will require RF design capabilities that support ultra-fast 5G speeds.

Read more...
Achieving lowest cost, scalable and dynamic wireless mesh network installations
CST Electronics Editor's Choice Telecoms, Datacoms, Wireless, IoT
In many situations it is desirable for sensors to be connected wirelessly in a mesh network as this saves infrastructure and cost since long cabling runs are not required.

Read more...