Power Electronics / Power Management


Not all batteries are created equal

13 November 2013 Power Electronics / Power Management

Unfortunately, the battery is also more often than not one of the highest costs on the bill of materials, making it the first target for any manufacturer looking to cut costs. However, before deciding to simply replace the battery with a cheaper imported ‘equivalent’, take a second to consider that not all batteries are created equal.

Once a battery has been manufactured and the final label applied, there is no possible way of differentiating a good quality battery from a poor one. Yes, the open circuit voltage can be measured, as can the voltage under load and, if the means are available, the capacity of the battery can be tested. But none of this will determine whether the battery has been manufactured in accordance with internationally accepted practices and, more importantly, whether it is going to be safe in the end equipment after a few months of use.

Battery manufacturing is a complex process, now more so than ever, given that most new battery powered devices are being designed with rechargeable lithium based batteries (Li-Ion and Li-Po). In the past, the old nickel based batteries (Ni-Cd and NiMh) were relatively easy and safe to manufacture. Lithium based batteries are far more complex, with far smaller margins for error in the manufacturing process.

However, as a result of the subsequent decline in demand for nickel based batteries, the industry is seeing a proliferation of small battery manufacturers who were once previously manufacturing nickel based batteries, now starting to produce lithium batteries.

Ordinarily, this would not be a bad situation; however, the vast majority of these small manufacturers do not have the facilities, equipment or the technical know-how to safely and consistently produce these lithium batteries. Yet, despite this, they continue to do so, regardless of the consequences. As a result, there is currently an influx of cheap and potentially dangerous lithium batteries finding their way into devices, with potentially disastrous consequences.

Results of a lithium battery exploding.
Results of a lithium battery exploding.

All rechargeable lithium batteries have the potential to catch fire, or even explode. That’s simply the nature of their chemical composition. Lithium is used in these batteries because it has extremely high electrochemical potential. But lithium is also extremely volatile and therefore potentially dangerous. It’s for this reason that reputable manufacturers take such care to protect against possible fire and explosion, by means of external safety devices.

So, if this possibility exists with good quality, reputably manufactured lithium batteries, just imagine the potential for disaster with cheap, substandard batteries produced in inferior facilities. A single lithium battery can cause untold damage if it catches fire, or worse still, explodes. A standard lithium ion penlight battery, for example, can burn at temperatures in excess of 600°C, with a violent open flame which should only be extinguished by means of a Halon extinguisher.

Today, Asia produces many no-name brand replacement batteries that are popular with South African manufacturers because of their low price. Many of these batteries, however, have been manufactured in substandard facilities, with very little, or no, quality control, despite their claims of ISO certification.

Of course, there are many reputable battery manufacturers in Asia, some of whom are in fact manufacturing on behalf of world famous electronic brands. However, there are far more who are anything but reputable. The problem is, it is impossible to know. Sitting half way around the world, on the other side of a website that claims to be a large worldwide manufacturer, one has no idea whether they are reputable, or if they’re even manufacturers at all.

Even if one were to pay the manufacturing facility a visit, without being a battery specialist and knowing something about the battery manufacturing processes, it’s impossible to know the difference between a good manufacturing facility and a poor one. Yet, despite this, countless South African companies continue to blindly put their faith in the hands of these Asian manufacturers or agents representing them, by simply choosing their batteries based on price and price alone.

To be assured of the quality and integrity of a battery powered product, one should choose a battery specialist company that knows what it takes to manufacture a quality battery, that knows which Asian manufacturers to use, and that audits and controls the quality and manufacturing processes. Or beware the consequences, as not all batteries are created equal.

For more information contact Uniross Batteries, +27 (0)11 466 1156, [email protected], www.uniross.co.za>



Credit(s)



Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Power efficiency and robustness in electronics design
Power Electronics / Power Management
Mouser Electronics recently announced a new eBook in collaboration with Analog Devices highlighting essential strategies for optimising power systems.

Read more...
USB Type-C-powered controllers
Future Electronics Power Electronics / Power Management
Diodes Incorporated has released two USB Type-C PD 3.1 extended power range sink controllers that can be embedded into battery-powered devices.

Read more...
Multicell battery monitoring
Altron Arrow Power Electronics / Power Management
The LTC6811 from Analog Devices is a multicell battery stack monitor that measures up to 12 series connected battery cells with a total measurement error of less than 1,2 mV.

Read more...
Full telemetry in tiny DC-DC converters
RS South Africa Power Electronics / Power Management
The FS160* series of µPOL DC-DC converters from TDK all offer full telemetry, provide increased performance, and are remarkable for extraordinary power density in the smallest sizes.

Read more...
Power IC supplies 1650 W
EBV Electrolink Power Electronics / Power Management
Power Integrations has announced a two-fold increase in power output from the HiperLCS-2 chipset with the new device now being able to deliver up to 1650 W of continuous output power.

Read more...
High-voltage step-down DC-DC converter
Altron Arrow Power Electronics / Power Management
The MAX17793 is a high-efficiency, high-voltage, synchronous step-down DC-DC converter with integrated MOSFETs operating over an input voltage range of 3 to 80 V.

Read more...
High-voltage contactors
RS South Africa Power Electronics / Power Management
TDK Corporation has announced two new additions to its high-voltage contactor portfolio for harsh environments: the HVC43MC with integrated mirror contact and the HVC45 with enhanced short-circuit current handling capability.

Read more...
Chokes rated at 36 A
RS South Africa Power Electronics / Power Management
TDK Corporation has launched the EPCOS SurfIND series, a new range of current-compensated ring core double chokes for high currents and surface mounting.

Read more...
RF arrestor provides robust protection
RFiber Solutions Power Electronics / Power Management
NexTek’s range of coaxial RF surge and lightning arrestors are designed and built to provide robust protection for any radio or coaxial RF transmission application.

Read more...
Wide-Bandgap Developer Forum 2025
Power Electronics / Power Management
To give designers the ultimate in design flexibility, the entire range of WBG power semiconductors will be provided including discretes, modules, and highly integrated solutions ranging from 40 V to 700 V for GaN and 400 V to 3,3 kV for SiC.

Read more...